Skip to content

Two ways to fill a role

Advertise the role yourself, or use a recruitment agency?

An agency looks for people, approaches them, assesses them against your brief and introduces the ones it rates, and it is paid when one of them is hired or in stages as the search runs. An advert does none of that: it tells people the role exists and leaves the decision to apply with them. Both are sound ways to hire, and they suit different roles.

The short answer

Use an agency when the people you need are not looking, the search must stay confidential, or nobody has time to read applications. Advertise the role yourself when you can describe it clearly and will read what arrives. Here, that means a role paying £50,000 or more, pay stated, every application sent only to you, and a charge per application rather than a fee on the hire.

What an agency does

It searches, including among people who are not job hunting, approaches them, assesses them against your brief and introduces the ones it judges suitable. It can manage interviews, offers and negotiation, and it can run a search without any public advert at all.

In the government’s definition, an employment agency finds work for people who are then employed and paid by the hirer. It cannot make them pay for that: an agency must not “charge a fee to a work-seeker for work finding services”.[1]

What an advert here does

It publishes the role as a public page and emails the people who chose that kind of work and that area. Everyone who reaches you chose your advert and applied to it themselves, and every application goes to you and to nobody else.

AboveMedian is not a recruitment agency. We do not search for, assess, select or introduce anyone, and job seekers are never charged anything.

The money

How each is paid

Agency fees for permanent roles come in two common shapes. A Crown Commercial Service guide to its 2018 to 2022 public-sector recruitment framework described contingency recruitment as “a non-exclusive recruitment service with payment on fulfilment”, priced as a percentage applied to the hire’s annual salary and paid on placement. It described executive search, for senior and specialist roles, as paid in stages as the search progresses, with the largest part due on appointment.[2]

The percentage itself is agreed between you and the agency. We have not found a current, independent figure for typical fees that we can cite, so we do not quote one. Ask each agency for its rate, what it counts as salary, and what happens if the person leaves soon after starting.

Here there is no fee on the hire. You pay per application received, against a published definition, at a rate agreed with you in writing before your first advert. What you pay depends on how many billable applications arrive, whether or not you hire from them.

Worth asking any agency before you brief it

  • The percentage, and exactly which figure it is applied to.
  • What happens to the fee if the person leaves in the first few months.
  • Whether anything is owed if the search ends without a hire.
  • Whether the same role is being worked by other agencies at the same time.

Side by side

An agency and an advert, question by question

Seven differences that decide which route suits the role. The agency column describes how agencies generally work, not any particular firm, and cites a source wherever the statement is about how they are regulated or paid.

What you are buying

A recruitment agency

A search: finding, approaching and assessing people, then introducing those the agency judges suitable.

AboveMedian

An advert: a public page for the role, emailed to people who chose that kind of work and area.

When you pay

A recruitment agency

On contingency, when someone the agency introduced is hired. On executive search, in stages as the search runs.[2]

AboveMedian

When an application that meets the published definition arrives, whether or not you hire.

How the price is set

A recruitment agency

Commonly a percentage applied to the hire’s annual salary, agreed with the agency.[2]

AboveMedian

A rate per application, agreed with you in writing before your first advert.

Who you hear from

A recruitment agency

The people the agency introduces to you.

AboveMedian

Everyone who chose your advert and applied, unfiltered.

Who assesses applicants

A recruitment agency

The agency, against your brief, before you see anyone.

AboveMedian

You. Nobody here assesses, ranks or filters anyone.

People who are not job hunting

A recruitment agency

Can be approached directly by the agency.

AboveMedian

Only reached if they registered for alerts about that kind of work and area.

A confidential search

A recruitment agency

Can be run without a public advert.

AboveMedian

Not possible: every advert is a public page.

When an agency is the better choice

  • The people you need are not looking

    An advert reaches people who are looking or who asked to be told. An agency can approach people who are neither.

  • The search has to stay confidential

    Replacing someone still in post, for instance. An agency can search without a public advert, and every advert here is public.

  • Nobody has time to read applications

    Every application here comes to you unfiltered, and nobody sorts them for you.

  • The field is small and the skills are scarce

    Where a handful of people could do the job, a specialist’s contacts may be worth more than any advert.

  • You want someone to run the process

    Interviews, offers and negotiation are part of what an agency can do. We do none of them.

When advertising it yourself makes sense

  • You can describe the role and its pay

    And someone on your side will read what arrives and reply to it.

  • You want to see every application

    Not a selection made before you see anyone.

  • You want the cost tied to applications

    Rather than to a share of the hire’s salary.

  • You want contact from the first message

    Applicants come straight to you, and the relationship is yours from the start.

Doing both

You can brief an agency and advertise the same role here. If you do, agree with the agency in writing how a person who applies to your own advert is treated if the agency introduces them as well, so a fee is not disputed later.

If you are a recruiter

Agencies can advertise their clients’ roles here too, under the same rules: pay of at least £50,000 stated on the advert, alerts only to people who chose that work and area, and applications sent only to the advertiser. An advert placed for a client says so, and says the application goes to the firm that placed it.

What advertising here asks of a recruiter

Agency or advert: common questions

How much does a recruitment agency charge for a £50,000 role?

There is no single rate. Fees for permanent roles are commonly a percentage of the hire’s annual salary, agreed with the agency and paid when someone it introduced is hired, or in stages for executive search. We have not found a current independent figure we can cite, so ask each agency for its percentage, what counts as salary and what happens if the hire leaves early.

Is AboveMedian a recruitment agency?

No. AboveMedian is a job advertising board. We publish your advert, email people who chose that kind of work and area, and send every application to you. We never search for, assess or introduce anyone, and job seekers are never charged.

Can I use an agency and advertise on AboveMedian at the same time?

Yes. Agree with the agency, in writing, how a person who applies to your advert directly is treated if the agency also introduces them, so a fee is not disputed later.

Start here

Advertise the role yourself

Tell us the role and the area and a person replies. There is no fee on the hire, nothing is charged for asking, and the rate per application is agreed with you in writing before your first advert.

Step 1 of 3

What are you hiring for?

The roles

What are you hiring for?

What kind of roles are you hiring for?

Pick the closest fit. One tap moves you on.

Three short steps. Nothing is charged and no account is created.

Where these facts come from

Every statement about another company on this page was read from that company's own current pages on 8 October 2026, except where an entry says it is as reported. Prices and terms change, so read the original before you rely on a figure.

  1. GOV.UK , Employment agencies and businesses: overview

    gov.uk/employment-agencies-and-businesses

    Checked 8 October 2026.

  2. Crown Commercial Service , Permanent Recruitment Services RM6002: customer guidance (a public-sector framework that ran from November 2018 to April 2022)

    assets.crowncommercial.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/RM6002-Customer-Guidance-Final-v3.pdf

    Checked 8 October 2026.